| FORT PIERCE, Florida — For the
first time in the four years she’s been labeled a killer and
drug trafficker, former Port St. Lucie doctor Asuncion Luyao
spoke publicly — addressing both the judge tasked with
punishing her and members of the community where she
practiced medicine for more than two decades after moving
there from New York.
The tiny 64-year-old Filipino-American grandmother said
she was disillusioned with the justice system and
disappointed with a jury’s verdict that convicted her of
manslaughter in the death of a longtime patient and also
found her guilty of five counts of trafficking pain pills
and one count of racketeering.
She expressed frustration with the former patients who
testified against her, calling their accusations “all lies.”
“I am saddened by the fact that those I tried to help
improve their lives and alleviate their suffering turned
against me,” Luyao said during her sentencing on April 29.
“I want to let you know that what I’ve done for 25 years in
this county, I only did to help people. I only did the best
I could.”
Shortly after speaking, Luyao learned her fate.
Senior Circuit Judge Dwight Geiger sentenced Luyao, who
already had lost her license to practice medicine, to 50
years in prison.
The sentence included 15 years for the manslaughter
charge and 20 years for the racketeering charge.
Both sentences will run at the same time.
He ordered her to spend 30 years in prison for each of
the five trafficking-in-oxycodone charges, which also will
run at the same time but after the other sentences.
Geiger didn’t have much choice. State law required a
minimum of 25 years on two of the drug charges.
Assistant State Attorney Erin Kirkwood asked Geiger for a
sentence of 60 years, saying Luyao fed the addictions of her
patients with prescriptions for large doses of painkillers,
which led to overdose deaths.
“She flooded the streets of the Treasure Coast with these
drugs with predictable results,” Kirkwood said.
Kirkwood said Geiger’s sentence was fair.
Luyao’s attorney, Joel Hirschhorn, called it a “death
sentence.”
“She’s 64 years old. She’s a frail woman,” Hirschhorn
said. “I think she’s in a state of shock, understandably
so.”
Prosecutors had charged Luyao with six counts of
manslaughter in the overdose deaths of six of her former
patients.
But the jury acquitted Luyao on five of those counts,
convicting her only in the March 2001 death of Julia
Hartsfield, who had been her patient since 1996.
Hartsfield’s husband sat in the back row of the courtroom
and watched the hearing, but he chose not to speak.
“This brings some closure for everyone involved,” said
Kirkwood, who was involved with the case even before Luyao’s
2002 arrest.
Connie Velie’s daughter, Tina Smith, was one of the
patients who died of an overdose for which Luyao was found
not guilty of manslaughter.
Velie said she still blames Luyao for both her daughter’s
death and the death of her son, who was also Luyao’s patient
when he died. Luyao was not charged in his death.
“I have two children I’ll never see again,” Velie said,
crying.
Throughout two trials — the first ended in a mistrial
last year — Kirkwood argued that Luyao essentially ran a
“pill mill” from her office in the old Village Green plaza.
The doctor’s goal, she said, was to make money by keeping
patients addicted to powerful narcotics.
Hirschhorn argued that Luyao was a compassionate doctor
who tried to help patients who complained of pain and had no
one else to turn to. She was “taken in” by some who lied and
manipulated her to get the drugs, he argued.
During the hearing, Luyao thanked her friends and family
who stuck by her.
Afterwards, Geiger allowed Luyao to remain in the
courtroom as one-by-one her family and friends sat down
across from her to speak to her. More than a dozen people
lined up for the brief chance to be close to her.
They were not allowed to touch her, and most cried as
they offered her words of love and support while Luyao
quietly thanked them.
“In my prayers, I always thanked God for giving me a
sister like Asuncion Luyao,” said Maria Nella. “I cannot
understand why God has chosen for her to bear this unique
cross, but I believe He has a purpose for her. I am proud to
be her sister.”
During her trials, Luyao did not reveal any emotions, but
she began to cry at her sentencing when her sisters spoke on
her behalf. They said her one fault is that she’s too
trusting.
“People came to her and manipulated her and played with
her compassion,” her sister-in-law Chary Mendoza said.
Luyao was one of the first in the nation to be charged
with causing the deaths of patients from prescription drug
abuse. |