|
WASHINGTON — The guilty plea by former Federal Bureau
of Investigation analyst Leandro Aragoncillo stealing
classified information while working for two vice presidents
marks what experts believe is the first conviction of a spy
from inside the White House.
“I can’t recall having someone ever stealing secrets from
the executive office of the president,” Roger Cressey, a
former member of the National Security Council and top
counter-terror expert during the Clinton Administration,
told the Star-Ledger’s Washington bureau.
“The bottom line is there is an inherent level of trust
that comes with any person who works at the White House and,
if individuals are so inclined, they can violate that
trust,” said Cressey. “Even with a highly selective
screening process, there are no guarantees.”
Aragoncillo pleaded guilty in Newark on May 4 to federal
charges of passing top secret and secret information to
Philippine opposition leaders when he worked from 1999 to
2002 as a staff assistant to military advisers in the vice
presidential offices of Al Gore and Dick Cheney, and later
as an FBI intelligence analyst in New Jersey.
Prosecutors said his aim was to help topple Philippine
President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.
James Bamford, the author of two books on the secretive
National Security Agency, said Aragoncillo’s case is “as far
as I know the first time somebody who worked in the White
House has actually been convicted of espionage.”
“There have been cases where people in the White House
passed on information for domestic political reasons but not
for a foreign country,” Bamford said. “I guess you would
have to question the hiring practices at the White House.”
While unsure how much information Aragoncillo stole,
Cressey said the “good news is that what he passed along to
the opposition probably had no real effect, and whatever
intent he had to help the opposition overthrow the
government failed.”
“The second point is he got caught and is going to jail,
and that is not insignificant,” said Cressey.
While swiping top secret documents from the White House
may be a unique case, Aragoncillo is hardly the first or the
most damaging spy to have slipped through the security
cracks while working for the U.S. Government. There have
been spies inside the Central Intelligence Agency, the FBI,
National Security Agency and the Pentagon.
Some of the most notorious cases include:
• Robert Philip Hanssen, a high level FBI agent arrested
in 2001 and later convicted of selling American secrets to
Moscow for $1.4 million in cash and diamonds over a 15-year
period. Officials said his treason was the “worst
intelligence disaster in U.S. history.”
• Aldrich Ames, a CIA counterintelligence officer and
analyst convicted in 1994 of selling U.S. secrets to the
Soviet KGB for a decade. He was paid some $2.7 million.
Ames’ information betrayed at least 30 sources, 10 of whom
were later executed by the Soviets.
• Jonathan Pollard, a civilian intelligence officer with
the Navy who was paid tens of thousands of dollars to spy
for Israel, and was sentenced to life in prison in 1987 for
supplying national intelligence information to a foreign
government.
• Ana Montes, the Pentagon’s top intelligence expert on
Cuba, pleaded guilty in 2002 to spying for the Cuban
Government for 16 years because she opposed U.S. policy
toward Havana.
• Ronald William Pelton, a communications specialist with
the NSA, was convicted in 1986 of spying for the Soviet
Union. Authorities said he passed on highly classified
information about U.S. intelligence collection locations to
the Soviets.
In Aragoncillo’s case, he acknowledged pilfering
documents on terrorism threats to U.S. interests in the
Philippines, names of confidential government sources,
situation reports on foreign countries and what he described
as “a blueprint” for how to overthrow a government.
Some of the information had been designated “top secret,”
the highest possible security classification, representing
material that, if released, could gravely damage national
security.
Aragoncillo said that he sent documents to his contacts
while physically working at the vice president’s office, at
the FBI and from his Woodbury home.
Prosecutors declined to characterize the impact of the
espionage, other than to say it did not cause any deaths.
Aragoncillo said the information was shared with six
other people, including former Philippine President Joseph
Estrada and three legislators.
Together, they hoped to topple Mrs. Arroyo.
Though the allegations first surfaced last fall, the
confession was still extraordinary. Its impact on diplomatic
or defense matters was not immediately clear.
The White House declined to comment.
Wearing shackles and a green prison uniform, Aragoncillo,
a Manila native, pleaded guilty before Senior U.S. District
Judge William Walls to four charges, including transmitting
national security secrets.
The espionage count carries a possible death sentence,
but prosecutors agreed to recommend a penalty of roughly 15
to 20 years in prison.
Walls set sentencing for Aug. 14.
Aragoncillo did not comment during the proceeding and was
led from the courtroom by U.S. marshals. His defense
attorney later said that Aragoncillo, a naturalized U.S.
citizen, was swayed by his feelings of loyalty to his
homeland but never intended to harm the United States.
U.S. Attorney Christopher Christie dismissed the
explanation.
“(Aragoncillo’s) betrayal is profound,” Christie said,
“and a disservice to his country and all the men and women
in the military and security positions around the globe who
take the oath and serve with honor and integrity.”
The plea had been in the works since September, when
Aragoncillo and Michael Ray Aquino, a Filipino living in New
York, were arrested after the FBI determined Aragoncillo
downloaded at least 100 documents from the Fort Monmouth
Information Technology Center.
Court records showed that Aragoncillo immediately began
negotiating with prosecutors.
Neither his attorney, First Assistant Federal Public
Defender Chester Keller, nor the lead prosecutor, Assistant
U.S. Attorney Karl Buch, would acknowledge any cooperation.
But in the last of 101 questions to the defendant at the
hearing, Buch asked Aragoncillo if he was willing to provide
more information about his co-conspirators and the coup
plot.
Aragoncillo replied in the same crisp way he answered the
previous 100 questions. “Yes, sir,” he said.
Aragoncillo had been a Marine for 16 years, rising to
gunnery sergeant, when he began working in July 1999 as a
staff assistant to military advisers in the office of Gore.
At the time, he had “top secret” security clearance.
He met Estrada a year later, when the then-Philippine
President visited the White House as part of an official
state visit. Within months, prosecutors said, an
unidentified legislator who accompanied Estrada on the trip
contacted Aragoncillo, and asked him to begin supplying
classified U.S. documents. Aragoncillo said he agreed.
Aragoncillo acknowledged that he continued to spy after
he began working as an FBI analyst in 2004. He said he often
passed information under an e-mail alias, “Juan Miguel,” and
that he used code words.
“Bayside” meant the U.S. Embassy in Manila. “Young
golfers” referred to Filipino army officers. Mrs. Arroyo was
known as “the Penguin.”
In September, Aragoncillo stole a copy of a “secret”
document outlining how to engineer a coup and set up a
transitional government. He admitted e-mailing the document
to a legislator who prosecutors have previously identified
as Sen. Panfilo Lacson, a vocal Arroyo opponent.
“The attached info could be used as ‘guidance’ if and
when you intend to install a military council and later
transition to a ‘civilian cabinet,’” Aragoncillo wrote.
“I’ll print it because we are preparing something like
this,” Lacson replied, according to Aragoncillo.
The case has roiled the Philippines, already known for
corruption, particularly after prosecutors in Newark last
month publicly named Estrada, Lacson and former Philippine
House Speaker Arnulfo Fuentebella as unindicted
co-conspirators. Each has denied any wrongdoing.
Aragoncillo’s guilty plea is expected to increase the
pressure on Aquino, his co-defendant, who has rejected plea
offers.
Prosecutors contend that Aquino, a former ranking officer
in the Philippine National Police, was a conduit between
Aragoncillo and Lacson.
The FBI began scrutinizing the two men after immigration
officials detained Aquino last spring for overstaying his
visa.
When Aragoncillo, identifying himself as a bureau
employee, tried to intervene, immigration officers contacted
the FBI.
Agents then began reviewing his work. |