| MONDAY, May 1, will be a defining
moment for millions of illegal immigrants in the United
States. On this day, countless numbers of them will join a
national boycott of work, school and trade under a mass
action called “A Day Without Immigrants.”
Organizers are quick to point out that it is not their
intention to bring down the nation to its knees, but rather
to focus attention to their critical situation as the U.S.
Congress deliberates on a comprehensive immigration reform
program.
To begin with, it’s unrealistic to expect that the
boycott will make a huge dent on the economy as a whole.
Immigrant advocates themselves are divided on this action,
some of them saying that it will do more harm than good.
Recent mass demonstrations across the nation have moved
lawmakers and policy-makers to take hardline positions, one
way or the other. Republican and Democratic legislators are
sharply divided on their approaches to immigration reform.
The Senate is inclined to approve a compromise bill that
will blaze a trail to citizenship for illegal immigrants
already in the country. But the House of Representatives
poses a hurdle to any decent immigration reform because of
its seemingly implacable stand on criminalizing undocumented
workers and residents in this country.
Both parties, facing crucial midterm elections in
November, may not be able to reconcile their differences,
raising the prospect of a watered down bill that will not be
palatable to all concerns, especially the more than 11
million immigrants who live in the shadows.
It seems only President George W. Bush can whip
recalcitrant Republicans into line, led by its right wing in
both Houses. But the President himself is treading gingerly
on the hot-button topic. While he insists on his guest
worker plan, he has not sent a strong signal to his troops
that he wants immigration reform passed as soon as possible.
Partisanship, regrettably, gets in the way of a
compassionate and sensible solution to this festering
problem. Democrats share the blame for the impasse in the
immigration debate. New York Sen. Hillary Clinton, a
longtime friend of immigrants and a potential Democratic
presidential contender in 2008, sings a different tune. She
now favors a two-tier approach to citizenship and
prioritizes tough border security, including fencing target
areas.
We have waited long enough to give deserving immigrants
their due. Now is the time to do it. |