| JERSEY CITY — A charge of attempted
murder filed against a 23-year-old Filipino-American accused
of attacking a man with a baseball bat was upgraded to
murder after the man died from a fractured skull on Tuesday,
nine days after the alleged beating.
Matthew Mandap, a former U.S. Navy personnel from Hancock
Avenue and Bowers Street, was charged with the death of
Mario Vargas Jr., 20, also of this city.
The charge was upgraded after Vargas, a Hispanic, died at
the Jersey City Medical Center on Tuesday morning, according
to Hudson County Prosecutor Edward DeFazio.
Mandap surrendered to police and is being held at the
Hudson County Jail in Kearny on $500,000 bail with no 10
percent option, DeFazio said.
DeFazio said Mandap, who was born in the U.S., recently
left the U.S. Navy. His father, Romie, is a native of
Pampanga, Philippines, and is running a deli.
The incident reportedly happened inside Mandap’s
third-floor apartment on Nov. 20. Mandap hit Vargas once in
the head with a wooden bat, knocking him to the floor, then
hit him a second time — possibly when Vargas was
unconscious, according to The Jersey Journal, quoting De
Fazio.
But Mandap’s brother, Philip, said Mandap told him he was
trying to defend himself and his friends after Vargas tried
to break into their apartment after being kicked out of a
party.
DeFazio confirmed to The Jersey Journal that Vargas was
with the group who broke into the building and into the
apartment.
Philip Mandap, who wasn’t present during the attack, said
his brother told him that Vargas was among a group of men
armed with baseball bats who broke through the building’s
two front doors and smashed into Mandap’s apartment.
The apartment door appeared dented and misaligned, and
was closed with a padlock, The Jersey Journal said. A
shattered TV and broken glass could be seen, it added.
Philip Mandap said his brother told him he was in a
relative’s apartment with his sister and grandmother when he
heard people breaking through the building’s two front
doors.
He said Mandap told him he called 911, but then heard
noises coming from his third-floor apartment and ran
upstairs with a baseball bat.
Mandap saw Vargas and others trying to break down a door
in the apartment to reach other people from the party,
Philip Mandap said.
Philip Mandap said his brother was surrounded by the
intruders, but fled when they heard sirens, leaving only
Vargas.
He said Mandap’s roommate came out of the room where he
was barricaded and, when Vargas lunged at him, Mandap hit
him with the bat. Philip Mandap said his brother told him
Vargas then lunged again, this time at him, and he hit him a
second time.
DeFazio said investigators believe Vargas was rendered
unconscious by the first blow and was defenseless on the
floor when hit the second time.
Vargas may have been trying to calm the situation when he
was attacked, DeFazio said. That’s the scenario described by
the friends and relatives of Vargas, who worked as a clerk
through the On Target employment agency, the The Jersey
Journal said.
But friends and relatives of Mandap expressed disbelief
that he would commit such a crime for no serious reasons.
“He was an altar boy, very polite, very resourceful and
responsible,” according to close friends of Mandap’s late
mother, Filipinas (Fay), who died of cancer in the mid-90s.
“He gave his mother so much joy until she died of lung
cancer. He was with the U.S. Navy and he comes from a decent
family.”
DeFazio said Mandap is facing a maximum sentence of life
in prison if found guilty.
He said the case will be presented to the grand jury
early next year. He added that Mandap’s family expressed
intention to hire a private counsel. |