|
Amnesty International (AI) has cited the alleged
mistreatment and abuse endured by a Filipino transgender
in the hands of a New York City police officer during a
2003 arrest as among the widespread “serious patterns of
police misconduct and brutality aimed at LGBT (lesbian,
gay, bisexual, transgender) people, including abuses that
amount to torture and ill treatment.”
In a first-of-its-kind report on police abuse of sexual
minorities in the United States, AI reveals that police
mistreatment and abuse of LGBT people nationwide go
largely unchecked due to underreporting and unclear,
under-enforced or nonexistent policies and procedures.
Along with reports of abuses compiled by AI was the
2003 incident in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn involving a
Filipino transgender who was arrested following a melee
with the police during an LGBT fund-raising event:
“When he (the Filipino transgender) gave the police his
ID and papers, an officer said, ‘I know what you are. I
know your kind. I just want you to know you’re never going
to have a family like me, kids like me, a dog like me. And
know that whatever you strap on between your legs will
never be as real or as big as mine. You’re going to end up
like the rest of your kind: without a job, homeless and
shooting up drugs.’
“The police put him in a cell with female arrestees.
“Officers walked past him repeatedly, mocking his name
and asking, ‘What is this thing?’”
AI said at least 20 LGBT people suffered injuries in
that Brooklyn incident and that a civil lawsuit against
the NYPD is now pending.
“Across the country, lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgender people endure the injustices of
discrimination, entrapment and verbal abuse, as well as
brutal beatings and sexual assault at the hands of those
responsible for protecting them — the police,” said Dr.
William F. Schulz, executive director of Amnesty
International USA. “Some, including transgender
individuals, people of color and the young suffer
disproportionately, especially when poverty leaves them
vulnerable to homelessness and exploitation and less
likely to draw public outcry or official scrutiny. It is a
sorry state of affairs when the police misuse their power
to inflict suffering rather than prevent it.”
The AI report also documents how even when LGBT people
report hate crimes, their complaints are often ignored.
The report includes plenty of New York-specific
material in this report.
The dense, 132-page report — “Stonewalled: Police Abuse
and Misconduct Against Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and
Transgender People in the U.S.,” available online at
www.amnesty.org — was based on a survey of the
largest police departments in 50 states and on hundreds of
interviews, and focused specifically on a half-dozen of
the biggest cities, New York City among them.
Even though the NYPD refused to respond to the AI
survey, the group was able to interview a number of New
York City police officers individually, according to Gay
City News.
Another example cited involved a white transgender
woman who was allegedly beaten, hogtied and dragged by
police officers across a hot pavement upon her arrest in
Sacramento, California. She was placed in the county main
jail cell with a male inmate who struck, choked, bit and
raped her.
That inmate received a mere three-month sentence. No
officer has been disciplined for the incidents surrounding
Kelly’s incarceration.
Seventy-two percent of police departments responding to
AI’s survey said they had no specific policy regarding
interaction with transgender people.
In New York City, the report says, “It is unclear
whether or not the NYPD has a specific policy that governs
interactions with transgender individuals.” |